In FOIA case, Va. Supreme Court draws ‘bright line’ upholding open meetings

Court rejects argument public business only means what’s on official agenda

In a split opinion on transparency laws, the Supreme Court of Virginia on Thursday upheld a more expansive definition of what counts as a public meeting of government officials.

This page requires Javascript.

Javascript is required for you to be able to read premium content. Please enable it in your browser settings.

kAmkDA2?m%96 42D6[ H9:49 46?E6C65 @? 2? :>AC@>AEF >66E:?8 E92E E@@< A=246 :? !C:?46 (:==:2> r@F?EJ E@ 5:D4FDD =@42= F?C6DE :? |2J a_a_ 27E6C E96 A@=:46 <:==:?8 @7 v6@C86 u=@J5[ A@D65 BF6DE:@?D 7@C E96 9:89 4@FCE 23@FE H92E <:?5D @7 >66E:?8D E96 AF3=:4 D9@F=5 36 ?@E:7:65 23@FE 2?5 H92E EJA6D @7 5:D4FDD:@?D 4@F?E 2D “AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m{2HJ6CD C6AC6D6?E:?8 7:G6 >6>36CD @7 E96 !C:?46 (:==:2> q@2C5 @7 r@F?EJ $FA6CG:D@CD 925 AFD965 7@C >@C6 =66H2J 7@C AF3=:4 @77:4:2=D E@ 9@=5 :?7@C>2= 82E96C:?8D[ 2C8F:?8 AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD D9@F=5 36 ?2CC@H=J 567:?65 2D >2EE6CD 2AA62C:?8 @? 2? @77:4:2= >66E:?8 286?52] k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?mp >2;@C:EJ @7 $FAC6>6 r@FCE ;FDE:46D C6;64E65 E92E 2C8F>6?E :? 2? @A:?:@? E92E A@:?E65 E@ E96 “3C:89E =:?6” @7 E96 ':C8:?:2 uC665@> @7 x?7@C>2E:@? p4E’D “DE2E65 AC6DF>AE:@? :? 72G@C @7 @A6? 8@G6C?>6?E]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m“%@ 25@AE E96 5676?52?ED’ 4@?DECF4E:@? — E92E 2 E@A:4 42??@E 36 AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD F?E:= :E 2AA62CD @? 2 7@C>2= q@2C5 286?52 — H@F=5 8FE E96 @A6? >66E:?8 AC@G:D:@?D @7 'u~xp[” yFDE:46 (6D=6J v] #FDD6== yC] HC@E6 7@C E96 >2;@C:EJ] “xE H@F=5 2==@H A@CE:@?D @7 @C 7F== 3@2C5D @7 DFA6CG:D@CD E@ >66E[ 5:D4FDD 2?5 564:56 4@F?EJ 3FD:?6DD :? D64C64J 3J H2:E:?8 F?E:= 27E6C E96:C AC:G2E6 5:D4FDD:@?D 2?5 564:D:@?D E@ A=246 2? :E6> @? 2 7@C>2= 286?52]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m%H@ !C:?46 (:==:2> C6D:56?ED 925 DF65 E96 4@F?EJ @G6C 2 4@>>F?:EJ >66E:?8 E92E E@@< A=246 E96 52J 27E6C 2 |2J b_[ a_a_[ AC@E6DE D@>6 4@F?EJ @77:4:2=D 492C24E6C:K65 2D 2 C:@E] %96 =2HDF:E 46?E6C65 @? 82E96C:?8D @7 4@F?EJ @77:4:2=D E@ 5:D4FDD E96 6G6?ED @7 E92E ?:89E]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m%96 6?E:C6 !C:?46 (:==:2> q@2C5 @7 r@F?EJ $FA6CG:D@CD 96=5 2? 6>6C86?4J >66E:?8 2E c A]>] @? |2J b`[ 3FE E96 =:E:82E:@? 46?E6C65 @? 2? 62C=:6C >66E:?8 2E ` A]>] 2EE6?565 3J 7:G6 DFA6CG:D@CD[ A@=:46 @77:4:2=D[ 4@F?EJ 6>A=@J66D[ >6>36CD @7 E96 4@F?EJ’D r:E:K6?D’ p5G:D@CJ q@2C5 7@C =2H 6?7@C46>6?E 2?5 “>@C6 E92? D:IEJ >6>36CD @7 E96 4@>>F?:EJ[” 244@C5:?8 E@ 4@FCE 5@4F>6?ED] s6DA:E6 “4@?7=:4E:?8 E6DE:>@?J[” E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE 4@?4=F565 E96 ` A]>] 82E96C:?8 67764E:G6=J D6CG65 2D 2 >66E:?8 @7 E96 r:E:K6?D’ p5G:D@CJ q@2C5] %9@F89 >@DE @7 E96 4@F?EJ’D 6:89E\>6>36C 3@2C5 @7 DFA6CG:D@CD 2EE6?565[ E9C66 @E96C DFA6CG:D@CD H6C6?’E :?G:E65]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m%96 A=2:?E:77D :? E96 42D6 2C8F65 E96 62C=:6C 82E96C:?8 D9@F=5 92G6 366? EC62E65 2D 2? @77:4:2= AF3=:4 >66E:?8[ EC:886C:?8 u~xp’D CF=6D 23@FE ?@E:46 E@ E96 AF3=:4 2?5 2446DD 7@C 2?J@?6 H9@ H2?E65 E@ 2EE6?5] %96 5676?52?ED :?D:DE65 :E H2D ?@E 2 AF3=:4 >66E:?8[ H9:49 >62?E u~xp 5:5?’E 2AA=J]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?mx? |2J a_a`[ E96 =@42= 4:C4F:E 4@FCE D:565 H:E9 E96 DFA6CG:D@CD[ CF=:?8 E92E E96 82E96C:?8 5:5?’E >66E E96 =682= C6BF:C6>6?ED E@ 36 4@?D:56C65 2 AF3=:4 >66E:?8]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m%96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE @G6CCF=65 E92E 564:D:@? 2?5 D6?E E96 42D6 324< E@ E96 4:C4F:E 4@FCE 7@C 7FCE96C AC@4665:?8D[ 4@?4=F5:?8 E92E 6?@F89 AF3=:4 @77:4:2=D 2EE6?565 E96 >66E:?8 E@ EC:886C @A6? >66E:?8 =2HD 2?5 E92E E96 E@A:4 2E 92?5 >6E E96 567:?:E:@? @7 “AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD” 3642FD6 :E 925 2 5:C64E 362C:?8 @? E96 4@F?EJ’D C6DA@?D6 E@ 2? :>A@CE2?E 6G6?E]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m“xDDF6D C6=2E65 E@ E96 C:@ED[ E96 FD6 @7 7@C46 3J A@=:46[ E96 FD6 @7 496>:42= 286?ED E@ BF6== E96 C:@ED 2?5 E96 AC@A6CEJ 52>286 E92E H2D 42FD65 H6C6 2== 5:D4FDD65[” #FDD6== HC@E6] “~?6 @7 E96 7:CDE C6DA@?D:3:=:E:6D @7 2?J 8@G6C?>6?E :D E@ AC@E64E E96 =:G6D[ D276EJ 2?5 AC@A6CEJ @7 :ED 4:E:K6?D] pD DF49[ :E :D 92C5 E@ :>28:?6 2?J D46?2C:@ :? H9:49 E96 q@2C5 H@F=5 ?@E D@@? 255C6DD 2 ?:89E @7 AC@E6DE 2?5 F?C6DE]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m%96 4@FCE 2=D@ 6>A92D:K65 E92E E96 AC@E6DED H6C6 E96 >2:? E@A:4 2E 2 “AC@A6C=J ?@E:465” >66E:?8 E92E E@@< A=246 ;FDE 9@FCD =2E6C[ 3@=DE6C:?8 :ED G:6H E92E E96 62C=:6C 5:D4FDD:@? D9@F=5 92G6 366? EC62E65 2D AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD DF3;64E E@ u~xp]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?mx? 2 5:DD6?E:?8 @A:?:@?[ r9:67 yFDE:46 $] q6C?2C5 v@@5HJ? 2?5 yFDE:46 r=6@ t] !@H6== H2C?65 2? @G6C=J 3C@25 567:?:E:@? @7 AF3=:4 3FD:?6DD H@F=5 4@?DEC2:? E96 7C66 7=@H @7 :?7@C>2E:@? 36EH66? 6=64E65 @77:4:2=D 2?5 E96 4@>>F?:E:6D E96J D6CG6] %96 5:DD6?E:?8 ;FDE:46D D2:5 E96J D2H 2? :>A@CE2?E 5:DE:?4E:@? 36EH66? :?7@C>2E:@? 82E96C:?8 2?5 @77:4:2= 24E:@? 3J AF3=:4 3@5:6D[ 2 =:?6 E96J 76=E E96 >2;@C:EJ @A:?:@? H@F=5 3=FC]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m“%96 ?6H 567:?:E:@? 5:D4@FC286D 4:E:K6?\@C82?:K65 :?7@C>2E:@?2= 82E96C:?8D 3J C6BF:C:?8 E96 2AA=:42E:@? @7 'u~xp ?@E:46 C6BF:C6>6?ED[ 6G6? :7 E96 AFCA@D6 @7 E96 >66E:?8 :D AFC6=J :?7@C>2E:@?2=[” E96 5:DD6?E D2JD]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?mx? 2 7@@E?@E6[ #FDD6== D2:5 E96 5:DD6?E:?8 ;FDE:46D’ G:6H[ :7 E2<6? E@ :ED “=@8:42= 4@?4=FD:@?[” H@F=5 2==@H 2 >2;@C:EJ @7 3@2C5 >6>36CD E@ 9F55=6 :? AC:G2E6 H:E9 =@33J:DED[ A@=:E:42= A2CE:6D @C 42>A2:8? 5@?@CD E@ 5:D4FDD “E96 =@42=:EJ’D 3F586E[ A@=:4:?8 :DDF6D[ E2I C2E6D[ =2?5 FD6 A6C>:ED[ 2?5 2?JE9:?8 2?5 6G6CJE9:?8 6=D6 E92E AC@A6C=J 4@F=5 4@>6 367@C6 E96 3@2C5 3FE 925 J6E E@ 2AA62C @? E96 286?52]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m“%9:D 42??@E 36 D@ 3642FD6 DF49 AC:G2E6 >66E:?8D 2C6 6I24E=J E96 EJA6 @7 324<\C@@>[ D64C6E:G6 562=:?8 E92E 'u~xp H2D 6?24E65 E@ AC6G6?E[” E96 @A:?:@? DE2E6D]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m|682? #9J?6[ 2 EC2?DA2C6?4J 25G@42E6 H9@ D6CG6D 2D 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 E96 ':C8:?:2 r@2=:E:@? 7@C ~A6? v@G6C?>6?E[ D2:5 E96 CF=:?8’D C62=\H@C=5 :>A24E AC@323=J H@?’E 36 2 “3C@25 DH66A:?8 E9:?8” 3642FD6 >@DE AF3=:4 3@5:6D 2C6 2=C625J >:?57F= @7 H92E 5@6D 2?5 5@6D?’E EC:886C @A6? >66E:?8 CF=6D] $96 D2:5 D96 E@@< 6I46AE:@? E@ E96 5:DD6?E’D 7@4FD @? 2 A9C2D6 :? ':C8:?:2’D EC2?DA2C6?4J =2H D2J:?8 ?@E9:?8 :? u~xp D9@F=5 36 4@?DECF65 E@ “5:D4@FC286 E96 7C66 5:D4FDD:@? 3J 8@G6C?>6?E @77:4:2=D @C 6>A=@J66D @7 AF3=:4 >2EE6CD H:E9 E96 4:E:K6?D @7 E96 r@>>@?H62=E9]” w6C G:6H @7 E92E =:?6’D >62?:?8[ D96 D2:5[ :D E92E “A6@A=6 H9@ H@C< :? 8@G6C?>6?E D9@F=5 DE:== 766= 7C66 E@ E2=< E@ 4:E:K6?D]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2?m“tG6? :7 J@F H6C6 ECJ:?8 E@ 8:G6 E92E D64E:@? 4C656?46[ 2== H6’C6 D2J:?8 96C6 :D E92E J@F D9@F=5’G6 8:G6? ?@E:46 @7 E9:D >66E:?8[” #9J?6 D2:5] “x7 :E’D D@ :>A@CE2?E E@ 36 23=6 E@ 92G6 E96D6 4@?G6CD2E:@?D H:E9 E96 AF3=:4[ E96? E96 AF3=:4 D9@F=5 <?@H 23@FE E96>]”k^DA2?mk^Am

k9C ^m

kAmk6>mk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^G:C8:?:2>6C4FCJ]4@>Qm':C8:?:2 |6C4FCJk^2m :D A2CE @7 $E2E6D }6HDC@@>[ 2 ?6EH@C< @7 ?6HD 3FC62FD DFAA@CE65 3J 8C2?ED 2?5 2 4@2=:E:@? @7 5@?@CD 2D 2 d_`4WbX AF3=:4 492C:EJ] ':C8:?:2 |6C4FCJ >2:?E2:?D 65:E@C:2= :?56A6?56?46] r@?E24E t5:E@C $2C29 '@86=D@?8 7@C BF6DE:@?Di k2 9C67lQ>2:=E@i:?7@oG:C8:?:2>6C4FCJ]4@>Qm:?7@oG:C8:?:2>6C4FCJ]4@>k^2m] u@==@H ':C8:?:2 |6C4FCJ @? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^72463@@<]4@>^E96G:C8:?:2>6C4FCJQmu2463@@<k^2m 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^EH:EE6C]4@>^|6C4FCJ':C8:?:2Qm%H:EE6Ck^2m]k^6>mk^Am